Hana Financial Group vs Shinhan Financial Group
Shinhan Financial Group holds the stronger position because its profit growth is accelerating every quarter while Hana's has slowed and even slipped quarter over quarter.
Hana Financial Group
Hana Financial Group is South Korea's #3 bank by profit, running deposits, loans, and wealth management.
Shinhan Financial Group
Shinhan Financial Group runs banking, cards, securities and insurance across South Korea's Big Five.
Dimension by dimension
| Dimension | Hana Financial Group | Shinhan Financial Group |
|---|---|---|
| Staying power of the core banking business | Spans the same range of regulated activities, banking, securities and insurance across the group, giving it a similarly durable base. | Runs banking, cards, securities and insurance under one group, giving it a diversified, regulated business base that is hard to dislodge. |
| Exposure to AI taking over the product | Its licensed banking and insurance functions sit outside what AI tools do, for the same reason its core business is not exposed to AI substitution. | Its regulated deposit taking, lending and insurance functions are not tasks that current AI tools or chatbots can replace. |
| How easily a bigger player could copy them | Faces the same kind of licensing and regulatory barriers, which keep outside tech entrants from stepping into its banking business. | Its banking license, branch network and customer base are protected by regulatory barriers that a large tech firm cannot simply replicate. |
| Pressure from rivals | Faces pressure from both KB and Shinhan, which are pulling further ahead in brokerage and wealth management fees, leaving Hana's non-banking profit share at just 6.4% against KB's 33.9%. | Faces pressure mainly from KB Financial's lead in group profit and from neobanks Kakao Bank and Toss chasing younger retail depositors. |
| Recent profit momentum | Net income rose 7.1% in FY2025 and stayed in the 2.40 to 2.49 trillion won range for H1 2026, but Q2 2026 net income of KRW 1,192.8 billion actually fell 1.4% from the prior quarter. | Net profit rose 11.7% in FY2025, 17.5% in Q2 2026, and 13.3% for H1 2026, growth that has held up across every recent period. |
| Business mix balance | Explicitly lagging in diversification, with non-banking activity contributing only 6.4% of profit compared to KB's 33.9%, leaving it more dependent on core banking income. | Numbers show steady across-the-board growth without any flagged weakness in how income is split between banking and other units. |
Questions people ask
- Shinhan Financial Group vs Hana Financial Group, which is growing profit faster?
- Shinhan is growing faster on every recent measure, with net profit up 11.7% for FY2025, 17.5% in Q2 2026, and 13.3% for H1 2026. Hana's FY2025 net income rose a slower 7.1%, and its Q2 2026 net income actually dipped 1.4% from the prior quarter.
- Are Shinhan or Hana at risk from AI replacing their products?
- Neither is. Both are marked unlikely to have their core product absorbed by AI, since regulated banking, lending and insurance services are not the kind of task AI tools take over.
- Could a big tech company copy Shinhan or Hana's business?
- No, both are rated blocked for that risk. Their banking licenses, branch networks and regulatory standing make them hard for an outside giant to simply replicate.
- Which company faces more competition, Shinhan or Hana?
- Hana faces broader pressure, being outpaced by both KB and Shinhan in brokerage and wealth management fee income, with its non-banking profit share far behind KB's. Shinhan's pressure is narrower, coming mainly from KB's lead in overall group profit and from neobanks chasing younger depositors.
- Is Shinhan Financial Group or Hana Financial Group in a stronger financial position right now?
- Shinhan looks stronger right now, with consistent double digit profit growth across FY2025, Q2 2026 and H1 2026. Hana posted slower FY2025 growth and its most recent quarter actually declined from the one before.
Other comparisons with these companies